How Annapolis HOA Boards Can Enforce Covenants Without Getting Sued?

Key Takeaways
- Annapolis HOA boards can enforce only what their governing documents authorize.
- Applying the same rule the same way to every owner is the strongest protection against a lawsuit.
- Owners must receive notice and a chance to be heard before fines.
- Fair housing requests require careful review.
- Early legal advice can keep disputes out of court.
The safest way for an Annapolis HOA board to enforce covenants is to treat every violation as a process, not a personal dispute. Lawsuits often arise when a board skips a step, overlooks a similar violation down the street, or misses a legal limit on its authority. A documented, predictable process protects both the board and the community.
What a Maryland HOA board Can (and Cannot) Enforce
A Maryland HOA board can enforce the declaration, bylaws, and properly adopted rules, including architectural standards, parking limits, and assessment collection. Before fining an owner, the board should give notice and a fair chance to be heard. However, federal and state law limit board power in several areas:
- Satellite dishes and antennas under the FCC’s OTARD rule.
- Unreasonable restrictions on solar panels.
- Rules that discriminate under fair housing law.
A board also cannot enforce a rule its governing documents never authorized or one adopted without proper procedure.
Consistent Enforcement: The #1 Defense Against a Lawsuit
HOA boards are often accused of selective enforcement of their own rules. This is the most common defense that we have seen homeowners use when they have been sued by an HOA, although it is not necessarily used in this form. A homeowner may argue the doctrines of estoppel or laches, which are ways of getting at the fundamental fairness of the situation. Maryland courts have narrowed this defense in recent years, and it can only be successful if the defendant argues that the HOA has failed to enforce the same exact rule, rather than not enforcing its rules in general.
Fines, Hearings, and Due Process Under Your Governing Documents
There are two things that are fundamental bedrocks of HOA law in Maryland. The first is that everything must be done according to the HOA’s governing documents. Not only must the rules be found in the documents, but also the HOA must follow the procedures for hearings and fines that have already been enumerated. The second is that a homeowner is allowed due process before they can be issued any type of discipline. They must have the opportunity to be heard and present their own side of the story.
Fair Housing and Reasonable Accommodation Traps to Avoid
Although the rules must be enforced in an even-handed manner, there are some ways that an HOA can find itself in trouble under Maryland and Federal law. For example, if the rule violation relates to a reasonable accommodation or a fair housing rule, the HOA can find itself accused of housing discrimination. A resident may be in violation of a no-pet policy, but the animal is one for assistance. A homeowner may be constructing a ramp in contravention of an HOA rule, but it is for access to their home. These laws do not necessarily give homeowners an unfettered right, but they will make a board have to think twice.
When to Escalate: Counsel, Mediation, or Court
A Maryland HOA should involve counsel as soon as a dispute could lead to fines, liens, litigation, or claims against the board. Escalation usually follows this order:
- Counsel: An attorney reviews the governing documents and confirms the board followed proper notice and hearing steps.
- Mediation: A neutral mediator can resolve neighbor or architectural disputes faster and at a lower cost.
- Court or commission: If talks fail, the association may file in circuit court. Montgomery and Prince George’s counties also have commissions that hear these cases.
You should not wait to hire an attorney because the situation can get out of hand before more detailed negotiations can occur to resolve the situation.
Maryland HOA Lawyers at Oliveri & Larsen Can Review Your Situation
The Maryland HOA lawyers at Oliveri & Larsen assist boards in difficult situations involving enforcement of rules. Our experienced legal team will provide the guidance you need. Call us at 410-295-3000 or contact us online to schedule a consultation. We have offices in Annapolis, Maryland, and serve clients in the surrounding areas.
